I've been to multiple luauas, and I think the Feast of Lele is one of the best for a couple reasons. I like the more intimate setting. Paradise Cove on Oahu is 500+ people, but this is more like 150. Some couples are seated up front, then 2 rows of longer tables for 6, then we sat at tables for 4 on a short rise, so we could still see the dancers. The drummers were immediately in back of us - talk about surround sound! A section of the seating went back further, so I'd book early to reserve a better seat.
Seating begins at 6pm. You get a lei and a drink, and can get photos if you want. However, photos were off to the side (at least they were by the time we arrived at 6:15), which I prefer to most luaus that force everyone in line to get a picture taken. The stage is in front of the beach, and you can see the sun set as the dancers present their program. Very nice. Bathrooms are outside of the theater area, in between the shops.
I enjoyed the format, where you had a couple courses from one island, then their dances, then a course from the next island gorup, then their dances, etc. The breaks in between give you time to run to the bathroom, and help ensure it's more spread otu than a normal intermission - good news for us women. I never had to wait for more than 1 person in front of me.
Food was served family style. I personally liked the Hawaiian food the best, and didn't care for the Tahitian at all, but I was pretty full by then, and it's just a matter of personal taste. They will bring you more of something if you ask. We also noticed that several of our waiters had traditional tatoos, some of them quite extravagent and detailed.
The Hawaiian dances were first. They did a couple kahiko numbers, and one or two auana dances. One or two of the girls were a little week in tahitian, but then, I dance hula in a formal halau every week, so I'm more critical than most tourists. Drinks were unlimited, but because we drove, we cut short our alcoholic intake.
Overall, the dancers were good. I've seen some better, some worse. However, the fire-knife dancer is one of the best we've seen. We really enjoyed his performance.
The chairs, although plastic, look nicer than most luau palstic chairs, and are slightly more comfortable. Each table has nice, white table cloths. Bring a jacket, ladies, in case the breeze gets cool after sundown.
There were a couple wahines out front selling hand-made jwerly and hand-carved statues. Some other luaus sell stuff, but it's not always made in Hawaii. We asked the wahine selling the masks to engrave ours with our name and anniversary date, which she did, and she also signed the mask.
What you don't get - the IMU demonstration (demonstartion of pig cooked in underground "oven") and some other traditional stuff that larger luaus include, no buffet, no drink coupons.
What you get - closer view, more intimate, refined setting, better service, unlimited drinks, lovely beach setting.
I have not been to the Old Lahaina Luau, so can't compare, but I can say that if you want a luau that is a little dfiferent from most of the others, this is the one.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.