We (four of us) stayed in a one-bedroom suite - Room 274, that faced the marina and partially the property next door (Humphrey's Half Moon). The room was more than spacious, and very clean. Bed in bedroom was comfortable, and they gave us lots of pillows which I really appreciated. The pull-out mattress has seen better days, but my 7-year-old twins didn't seem to notice. The included buffet breakfast was very good, and the waitstaff was always professional, quick and courteous. The little outdoor pool and outdoor hot tub were perfect for hanging out after a day of touring, and it was additionally nice that you could get drinks from the bar and bring them out to the pool. The bar food was marginal - standard hotel bar stuff - we did it one night and never did it again. But the bartenders were great! We really enjoyed the marina view from our room (which we requested) but others may prefer the bay view (you look over a parking lot, a road, and then the harbor/San Diego skyline). One heads up: Next door - Humphrey's Half Moon is a hotel (not as nice as Bay Club, by the way, my husband has stayed there) and outdoor concert venue. Depending on which end of the building you stay on, you can hear (and even see) the performers from your balcony - so don't expect quiet before 10PM. On the flip side - you can get a free concert! We enjoyed Crosby, Still and Nash and the Indigo Girls during our visit. We would definitely stay here again.

My wife along with another couple made reservations thru the hotel. We were using one of their promos, “Dinner for two and a room with a view” for $189.00 plus tax that included free parking (usually $5.00) and dinner for two. The other night was $139.00 plus tax. A breakfast buffet is included for all guests.

I spoke to Tim, the night manager and set everything up for our April visit. We booked one room with a Bay view and the other with a Marina view. I wanted to make sure that the balconies for each room were able to accommodate all four of us so we could use either balcony. Tim actually went and looked at the balconies and locked in the rooms.

Unfortunately, the morning of our departure, the other couple called to say her husband was sick. I called the hotel to see what options we had. I know the hotel has a 48 hour cancellation policy but when I explained the situation and that we would re-book two weeks later the lady on the phone (can’t remember her name) said no problem. Thank-you! They could have dinged us for the one night.

Two weeks later the four of us arrive at the hotel at noon. We checked in at the front desk but only one room was ready. The other room would be ready around 3 pm. They took my cell number and said they would call when it was ready. We took all our bags to the room that was ready and had lunch at the hotel. The lunch was very good and no more expensive than your typical restaurant. Later we took a walk out to the grass area on the Bay side of the hotel. Excellent views.

Just after 3 pm Tim called and said the other room was ready. We met Tim at the reservation desk and he said that the room we had taken our bags to wasn’t one of the rooms he had reserved for us. Then he took us thru the Hotel and showed us about 6 different suites! Cool. Have never had that happen before. We ended up choosing a suite on the first floor on the corner with a Marina view for our friends. It had a HUGE balcony. We could have put 15 people on it. Since we now planned on using this balcony for our cocktail hour(s) my wife and I chose a suite with a Bay view on the second floor without a balcony.

We had an excellent dinner at the hotel that was included in our package. Everything was cooked perfectly. Tim even came by to say hello. Nice touch. Service was good as well and the view can’t be beat.

The breakfast buffet was good both mornings. Bacon, sausage, eggs, fresh fruits, etc. with orange juice and apple juice. It wasn’t very crowded which was nice also.

The hotel is an older property but very well kept. We noticed they were refurbishing several rooms during our stay but never heard any noise.

The staff was great. Thank-you, Tim and the rest of the staff. Would definitely stay at the Bay Club again. Thanks for reading.

This is my second visit to Shelter Island. I much preferred this property to my other stay at Kona Kai. Shelter Island is a thin strip of land, and the architecture of this building provides water views for all rooms. The service was excellent. I found this facility to be relaxing and peaceful.

Shelter Island is a short drive from the airport and within walking distance of several restaurants. However, I would recommend renting a car if you stay here. I found it very easy to drive to all the attractions from here. There is a small public beach across the street and about a ten-minute drive to Ocean Beach. It is a quieter part of town if you're looking for a more peaceful place to stay.

A nicely maintained pace right on the marina - with the Bay across the street.

Decor is 60s-70s California, a bit broken in, but well maintained and clean.

Staff is very helpful, friendly and low-key.